The Corrections: Hemingway Editor scores Nobel Prize winning author’s prose as “poor”
I am a word nerd. I love to geek out on weird and wonderful applications like Scrivener, Microsoft Word, Grammarly and the Hemingway Editor. These programs are innovative and can do some of the heavy-lifting for writers, especially in commercial writing, social media and journalism, catching spelling mistakes and proofing for small errors. But for novelists, poets and short story writers, editing programs are like talking to your drunken roommate from college; they don't always make a lot of sense. Allowing an editing program to decide how you should write is a critical mistake. Writing software has certain weaknesses, just check out the infamous spell check poem which proves conclusively that spellcheck is not the boss of you. Editing programs cannot detect rhythm or poetic metaphor or choose when the passive voice is more powerful than the active voice. Complex sentence structure baffles the algorithms of these applications. One day maybe, but not now. Editing and spelling software cannot replace education or instinct. Writers need to learn the rules in order to make … [Read more...] about The Corrections: Hemingway Editor scores Nobel Prize winning author’s prose as “poor”
Writing in the Age of Insanity
I flipped on the news early Monday morning, and there was a linguist analyzing what had emerged from Trump's mouth at a rally. The newscaster, Joy Reid, was earnest as she read a series of words that made no sense. Like a jazz singer scatting, Trump had tossed up a word salad of epic proportions. "He says he has the best words.... but he seems to be using all the words, regardless of whether they make sense or not," she said. The woman is a writer so she was experiencing the same thing I was—pain. She repeated various sections of his speech, searching for the secret message underlying the words. Was there any? The linguist, John McWhorter, broke it down for her. "When you're processing language, the first thing that comes into your brain is the tone, the music, then the content." Like animals in a forest, the strange noises emerging from Trump's mouth carried an emotional code, though the string of nonsense was utterly lacking in any coherent meaning. For a writer, this can be crazy making. Sure, we deal in the musicality of language, but writers spend an inordinate amount of … [Read more...] about Writing in the Age of Insanity
